Comments on: American Idol - Top 9 Perform Dolly Parton Classics

By: April K

April K — Wed, 02 Apr 2008 18:07:34 +0000

Sorry Matt, I have to say I like Christy’s rankings too! I am not a fan of Syesha and I think she is arrogant. I couldn’t believe KLC’s comments last night both to Simon and about not trying to impress her mother right now…she has to go soon!

By: Katie

Katie — Wed, 02 Apr 2008 17:01:26 +0000

I agree with Christy’s order on who did worst to best. And I agree that the judges were totally off their game last night. I usually always agree with what Simon has to say but I think someone might have left the plunger in the toilet when Simon used the rest room before the show. He was pissy about something thats for sure. I think Brooke started off the show great and I thought Jason and Carly were awesome last night as well. So hani voted a million times for those 3 to make sure they don’t get the short end of the stick tonight. I pray that Ramiele or Kristy goes home this week and then the other next week. Then we will for sure have the best remaining contestants ever.

By: Christy

Christy — Wed, 02 Apr 2008 15:41:42 +0000

Since our DVR sucks, here’s the rundown on Michael from MSNBC.com . . .

“Michael Johns closed the show with “It’s All Wrong, but It’s All Right,” and because Fox was in a hurry to get to the “Hell’s Kitchen” premiere, there wasn’t much time for idle chitchat from the judges. That’s a shame for Johns, since he got nothing but praise.

Randy Jackson praised him for “bringing it up a notch every week,” while Simon said it was the best he’d ever heard Johns sing.” YEA, Michael!!!

And of course I would do a little shuffle in the rankings . . .

9 - Ramiele
8 - Kristy Lee Cook
7 - Syesha Mercado (Please go home!!!)
6 - Jason Castro
5 - Brooke White
4 - Carly Smithson (Like Brooke’s style better but she’s undeniably super talented!)
3 - David Archuleta
2 - Michael Johns (Love him!)
1 - David Cook (Has surprisingly grown on me!)

By: Higgins

Higgins — Wed, 02 Apr 2008 15:39:56 +0000

Simon was in a foul mood, Paula was high as a kite, and Randy was his usual “screen door on a submarine” self. HOWEVER, I LOVED last night. Michael Johns reminded me of why he’s on this show: when he’s hot, he’s burning hot. Archuleta was finally back to his strong suit. And even David Cook, who apparently was taken to the hospital for heart palpitations after the show, was strong on a sort of “off” week for him. I loved Carly, and can’t understand for the life of me why Simon seems to have it in for her. I like Ramiele but agree that she’s so close to gone. KLC is officially the new Sanjaya: no one likes her, yet she won’t go away. Syesha screwed up, let’s just admit it. You CANNOT do epic Whitneys and expect not to get panned. Besides, am I the only person in America who thought she was slightly flat on that last vocal run? Anyone? Seriously? She is safe through this week, though. Now that Chikezie is gone, Syesha will be here for a few more weeks. My bottom three: Ramiele, KLC, and Castro.

By: Jill

Jill — Wed, 02 Apr 2008 14:54:39 +0000

My house was a crazy house last night so while I watched idol, I couldn’t devote my full attention to it. I think Ramiele will be the one to go or maybe Syesha. Loving David Cook. Carly looked great until you got to the leggings. Sorry, sweetie, you can’t pull them off. Don’t feel bad, I can’t either.

By: Dolly Parton Lover

Dolly Parton Lover — Wed, 02 Apr 2008 14:06:30 +0000

Omg, Dolly Parton was so wonderful on Idol tonight! You truly forget how great Dolly is until you see her and then you fall in love all over again. What an amazing lady!